Was louis riel a hero. Louis Riel: A Hero Or Villain? 2022-10-19
Was louis riel a hero Rating:
6,7/10
1919
reviews
Louis Riel is a controversial figure in Canadian history, and opinions on whether he was a hero or not vary widely. Some see Riel as a hero who fought for the rights of Indigenous peoples and the French-speaking Métis community in Canada, while others view him as a traitor who instigated violence and rebellion against the Canadian government.
One argument in favor of Riel as a hero is that he stood up for the rights and interests of the Métis and Indigenous peoples in Canada, who were often marginalized and mistreated by the government and the dominant Anglo-Canadian society. Riel was a leader in the Red River Rebellion of 1869-70, which was sparked by the Canadian government's attempt to annex the Métis-majority region of Red River (now part of Manitoba) without consulting the local population. Riel and other Métis leaders formed a provisional government to resist the annexation and negotiate with the Canadian government for better terms. Riel also played a key role in the North-West Rebellion of 1885, in which he and a group of Indigenous and Métis fighters took up arms against the Canadian government in protest of its policies towards Indigenous peoples.
Another reason why Riel might be seen as a hero is that he was a visionary and a man ahead of his time. Riel was a devout Catholic and a deeply spiritual man who believed in the value of education and the importance of preserving Indigenous and Métis cultures. He also had progressive ideas about democracy and political representation, and he fought for the establishment of a just and fair society in which all people were treated with dignity and respect. Riel's ideas and actions inspired many people, and he is remembered as a pioneer and a champion of social justice in Canada.
However, there are also valid arguments against Riel as a hero. Riel's actions during the Red River Rebellion and the North-West Rebellion resulted in violence and death, and he was ultimately convicted of treason and executed by the Canadian government. Some see Riel as a reckless and divisive figure who instigated unnecessary conflict and brought suffering upon his followers. Additionally, Riel's mental health has been called into question, and some have argued that he was not fully in control of his actions and should not be held fully responsible for the consequences of his rebellion.
In conclusion, whether Louis Riel was a hero or not is a matter of perspective. While he stood up for the rights of Indigenous and Métis peoples and had visionary ideas about democracy and social justice, his actions also resulted in violence and conflict. Ultimately, it is up to each individual to decide whether Riel's contributions outweigh his mistakes, and whether he should be remembered as a hero or not.
Louis Riel An Innocent Hero Or Deviant Villain History Essay
When Riel returned to St. The Red River Rebellion of 1869 was a necessary move for the Métis as they were constantly being taken advantage of due to their half-breed nature. Although I was convinced that from a humane standpoint, mine was the better plan, I had confidence in his faith, and that God would listen to him. Hero Or Villain: Andrew Jackson 716 Words 3 Pages Hero or Villain: Andrew Jackson Andrew Jacksons presidenicy was very complicated. Though his actions are a clear betrayal to the British Crown he was a hero in the eyes of the Métis; protecting their culture, rights and claims to the land of Manitoba. With a group of armed Métis followers, they were able to take control of a Hudson Bay trading post called Fort Garry and defended their territory in a subsequent raid by government troops, during which the Métis captured several of their attackers.
Loui Louis Riel: A Canadian Hero 1914 Words 8 Pages He helped create a province that had rights that were best for his people and in doing so, solidified their future. Macdonald used stall tactics, and Riel and the Metis grew impatient and frustrated, and on March 19, Riel declared Provisional Government at Batoche. He was banished from Canada and still came since at one point of his life he became insane thinking that he was a prophet. Others look at Cromwell as a traitor who let his ambition do the exact opposite of what Parliament fought for and cause him to kill anyone that opposed him. Many northerners were indifferent about the issue Why Is John Brown A Hero 85 Words 1 Pages I think John Brown was a hero, because he tried to find ways to free slaves.
Louis Riel was a hero because he fought for his beliefs and what he thought was right. In a textbook, you might find articles that say he betrayed the government or you may find an article online that say he is a true Canadian hero. His perspective on how he dealt with manner is still debated today. This event led the government to see Louis Riel as a national villain and brand him as a traitor against British Crown. While attempting to convince U.
If Canada refused to cede to Métis land claims, Riel would invite German immigrants in the United States to invade Ontario, Quebec and the Maritimes, compensating them with what is now northern Ontario. The act also gave way for the making of French and English the two official languages of the province allowing people in Manitoba to use either French or English in schools and governments. Andrew Carnegie: Heroic Or Hero? News of the execution spread quickly, and caused widespread outrage in Eastern Canada. The evidence can lead us to only one of two conclusions. The first action Riel undertook as leader of the Métis was to disrupt the Canadian surveyors as they crossed into the Red River area in October 1869. As of the meantime, Riel was living in a Metis community in Montana.
When Riel was 14, he went to study at the College de Montreal, and was a good student whom received a broad and excellent education in many things, including languages and the sciences. This proves that his pride in his name and refusal to blacken his name with a lie is a complete shock compared to his previous actions with Abigail which is the reason to why his name is currently bad. For his bravery and unyielding effort over the course of a decade, I believe Louis Riel is a hero to Canadian culture and its history. Andrew Carnegie: A Hero Or Hero? Louis Riel would be classified as a martyr due to his actions and contributions for his religion as a Metis man. I believe that Riel is a hero because he stood up for the rights of the Metis to the Canadian government during the Red River Settlement and the Northwest Rebellion.
Riel also had the choice of negotiating peacefully; however, he went forth thinking rebelling was the only choice. Being a martyr requires more than just a cause, it requires the individual to have strong beliefs for their religion, and then being killed due to those beliefs. I believe that Riel is a hero because he stood up for the rights of the Metis to the Canadian government during the Red River Settlement and the Northwest Rebellion. Was Napoleon A Hero Or Villain Dbq Essay 732 Words 3 Pages Napoleon came into rule after Robespierre and ruled as emperor of France. A nation council of the Metis became the real authority in Red River.
Not only that, but he could also be seen as a tragic hero. He allowed the English people to become part of the provisional government he created. He caused the Indian removal Act, Trail of Tears, and the Notification crisis. Riel himself was a former student then St. He was also a leader of the Metis and Red River territory. Grant to threaten to invade Canada if it did not respect the terms of the Manitoba Act, Riel underwent a religious experience in St.
For that reason, Louis had to spend 5 years out of Canada. However, Riel identified strongly with the Francophone Metis. Louis Riel stood for the protection of the Métis; and because of his attempt to preserve the Métis way of life; he was considered to be a traitor to the British crown and thus was hanged for six accounts of treason. Since the hanging of Riel for treason in 1885, his legacy and reputation has been under continuous scrutiny and invented and reinvented to suit the political, ideological and philosophical agendas of historians, Political Scientists, politicians, policy makers, ethnic groups and the majority of Canadian Citizens. Louis Riel was the leader in the 2 rebellions. He was a patriot who stood up for his people and his beliefs. Even with regard to French immigrants and French-Canadians coming to Manitoba from the U.
They killed around two hundred men but in the end the government troops were to powerful and they quickly and swiftly defeated the Métis; Louis Riel was captured. Regardless what others may believe, Louis Riel should be remembered as a hero. Terrified and worried because of that incident, Louis Riel escaped to the United States in 1870 when the Metis needed him the most. This basically makes his ego 10 times bigger. He would rally the French-speaking Metis and the English-speaking half-natives together to protect their interests from the conflicting interests of those in the east.
He was chosen to travel to Québec, and entered studies that would eventually lead to priesthood. Being a normal man, the rich disliked him for his opinions that did not fit the rich men and women their needs. Louis Riel: Historical Hero Louis Riel is a well-known figure in Canadian history. . While Louis Riel improved the lives of the Métis he was also responsible for the development of the province of Manitoba.
