Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes. Analysis: Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes? 2022-10-22
Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes Rating:
5,8/10
1868
reviews
Child soldiers are children under the age of 18 who are recruited by armed groups to participate in armed conflict. They may be used as fighters, cooks, porters, or for other tasks. Many child soldiers are forced to participate in armed conflict against their will and are subjected to physical and psychological abuse. The use of child soldiers is a grave violation of international law and human rights.
The question of whether child soldiers should be prosecuted for their crimes is a complex one. On the one hand, child soldiers are often coerced into participating in armed conflict and may not fully understand the consequences of their actions. They may also be under the influence of drugs or other substances, which can impair their judgment. On the other hand, child soldiers may commit serious crimes during armed conflict, including murder, rape, and other acts of violence.
There are a number of different approaches that have been taken to address the issue of child soldiers. Some argue that child soldiers should be treated as victims of conflict and should not be prosecuted for their crimes. Others argue that child soldiers should be held accountable for their actions, but that their age and circumstances should be taken into account in determining the appropriate punishment.
One approach that has been used in some countries is to provide rehabilitation and reintegration programs for child soldiers. These programs can help child soldiers to overcome the trauma of their experiences and to reintegrate into society. Some countries have also established special courts or tribunals to deal with the crimes of child soldiers. These courts may take into account the age and circumstances of the child soldiers, as well as the severity of their crimes, in determining the appropriate punishment.
Ultimately, the decision of whether to prosecute child soldiers for their crimes should be based on a careful consideration of the individual circumstances of each case. It is important to recognize that child soldiers are often victims of conflict and may have been coerced into participating in armed conflict. At the same time, it is also important to hold child soldiers accountable for their actions and to ensure that justice is served.
Should child soldiers be prosecuted?
These contributions help keep our journalism free and accessible to all. Most child soldiers are brainwashed by use drugs and alcohol. Personal research has been conducted and has… Pros And Cons Of Involuntary Child Soldiers Child soldiers should be given amnesty unless they did it voluntarily. To ensure force protection and self-defense, and to collect intelligence, the militaries of Canada and the United States detain child soldiers during armed conflicts. The purpose of DDRR programming is so much that they allow for these violent children to be rehabilitated, as such would prosecuting them really be the best way to act? Capital punishment for persons under 18 violates the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Convention on the Rights of the Child. They come to the army in hopes of safety. They are forced into fighting.
They use illegal drugs and alcohol. In these situations, prosecuting child soldiers may be needed under the guarantee of a fair trial, and respect the principle of child best interest, and for the purpose of rehabilitation and reintegration Amnesty, 2000. It is important that child soldiers are included in post-war justice, so that the whole community can see that the perpetrators of human rights violations are punished. The author believes that innocent kids should not be selected to fight as soldiers, lose their innocence killing people, witnessing violent scenes and suffer because of war. For instance, the Iraqi Juvenile Law 1983 stated that the criminal responsibility age is 9 years old, while the Syrian Law 1974 sets it at 7 years, the Sudanese Law 1983 sets the age at 10 years, and the Yemeni Law 1992 sets the age for criminal responsibility at 15 years old. These children knew exactly what they were doing and should not be excused from their actions simply because they are thought to be too young to take responsibility. E-Journal of Law, 2 2 , 15-29.
Analysis: Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes?
And at what age are children responsible for war crimes before the law? Some countries help the kids to prepare for this by forcing other soldiers that ran off on to their knees to be killed. Why do child soldiers fight? Challenges in establishing the accountability of child soldiers for human rights violations: Restorative justice as an option. I think these kids should be put into prison because some are happy they have hurt US soldiers, some stab people a rehab and some kids bragged about it. A 14-year-old child soldier was reportedly executed the previous year. Letting someone go after killing so many people is not fair to the deceased family.
Should Child Soldiers Be Prosecuted For Their Crimes?
In some cases, children do join the armed groups with free will, and they do committee atrocities against others with no corrosion or force. They do not choose to fight or kill. You feel like you're becoming part of them, part of the rebels. They deserve amnesty because they were drugged and forced into fighting in the Child Soldiers In The Military Analysis 852 Words 4 Pages Small hands, belonging to children, wrapped around a gun, fingers on the trigger. After the war, the government turned around and said those kids need to be prosecuted. Show your support as we build the future of news media by Become a member of The New Humanitarian Support our journalism and become more involved in our community.
Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes
Most child soldiers are brainwashed by use drugs and alcohol. In this situation, the society who is responsible for protecting and guarding these children have become the source of danger that threatens them, the community members from parties, political groups, armed groups, and even families and tribes are the one who recruits children into their armed forces and shove them towered participating in hostilities. ISIS Child Soldiers in Syria: The Structural and Predatory Recruitment, Enlistment, Pre-Training Indoctrination, Training, and Deployment. Each child were held in hostilities and couldn't have to opportunity to not fight. The use of child soldiers increased dramatically over the past years and it is clearly a huge issue.
Should Child Soldiers Be Prosecuted For Their Crimes Essay
The ICC issued an arrest warrant for him in October 2005 for crimes against humanity, including enslavement of children. If kid did any bad crime such as murder in America they could be tried as an adult and go to jail for a long time. I have come to realize that child soldiers are no different than children who commit crimes in the US, though the crimes they commit are far worse than those in the US. Although this might seem unrealistic, it is a reality for thousands of pre-adolescents around the world. Prosecution of a child should always be regarded as a measure of last resort and the purpose of any sentence should be to rehabilitate and reintegrate the child into society. Medical treatment is instrumental in getting former child soldiers rehabilitated and reintegrated.
Why Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes?
. Fagan, T, et al. Many of the most aggressive and abusive acts of wartime have been committed by child soldiers. Children and armed conflict. They act and take upon the roles of real combatants, causing the people of the public to act in different ways.
Analysis: Should Child Soldiers Be Prosecuted For Their Crimes
Although children volunteered or were told to hold these positions they had no choice. So yes they should be persecuted but only for a short amount of time. Conclusion The focal point we focus on is that holding child soldiers responsible for their actions do not mean they should be prosecuted in front of criminal courts. They lack the mental maturity and judgment to express consent or to fully understand the implications of their actions. As a result, that will require children to understand the concepts about race, ethnicity, religion which can be so complicated for them, therefore it is hard for children to be able to fulfill this intent taking into consideration its complicity and high requirements Nobert, 2011. This shows how child soldiers are forced into war whether it is because they are being forced, or because they have nowhere else to go.
