The civic perils of homeschooling. Critique 2022-10-20
The civic perils of homeschooling
Rating:
5,5/10
1242
reviews
Homeschooling, or the practice of educating children at home instead of sending them to a traditional school, has become increasingly popular in recent years. While there are certainly some benefits to homeschooling, such as the ability to tailor the educational experience to the specific needs and interests of the student, there are also significant civic perils associated with this approach to education.
One of the primary civic perils of homeschooling is the lack of socialization opportunities for students. Traditional schools provide a unique opportunity for children to interact with their peers, develop important social skills, and learn to navigate group dynamics. These interactions are crucial for children's personal and emotional development and help to prepare them for the real world. In contrast, homeschooled students may miss out on these valuable experiences, which can have a negative impact on their overall development and ability to function effectively in society.
Another civic peril of homeschooling is the potential for isolation and disconnection from the larger community. Traditional schools serve as hubs of community activity, where students and families can come together to participate in extracurricular activities, attend events, and engage with their neighbors. Homeschooled students may be less likely to participate in these activities, leading to a disconnection from the broader community. This disconnection can be particularly pronounced for families who homeschool their children due to social or cultural differences, as it may further exacerbate feelings of isolation and marginalization.
Additionally, homeschooling can also perpetuate inequities and social divides. Traditional schools serve as a key source of access to resources and opportunities for many families, particularly those from disadvantaged backgrounds. By choosing to homeschool their children, some families may inadvertently create barriers to these resources and opportunities, leading to further disparities in education and societal outcomes.
Finally, the lack of oversight and accountability in the homeschooling process can also pose civic perils. Traditional schools are subject to state and federal regulations, as well as accreditation processes, which ensure that students are receiving a high-quality education. In contrast, homeschooled students may not receive the same level of oversight and may not be held to the same standards as their peers in traditional schools. This can have a negative impact on the overall quality of education received by homeschooled students and may result in a lack of preparedness for higher education or the workforce.
In conclusion, while homeschooling may have its benefits, it also presents significant civic perils that should be carefully considered. These include the lack of socialization opportunities, disconnection from the larger community, perpetuation of inequities and social divides, and lack of oversight and accountability. It is important for families to weigh the pros and cons of homeschooling carefully before making a decision and to consider the potential impact on their child's overall development and preparedness for life in a diverse and interconnected society.
Homeschooling and the Question of Socialization Revisited on JSTOR
Where are the premises? Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute. In these ways, the school classroom, ideally, and the relations within it, is a model of some core aspects of citizenship. Cheng used a measuring instrument or questionnaire called the " content-controlled political tolerance scale. Religion and American education: Rethinking a national dilemma. Reich do not base their worries on solid evidence. This is 15 to 30 points higher, on average, than public-school students, whose average is the 50 th percentile.
Next
The Homeschooled More Politically Tolerant?
Homeschooling across America: Academic achievement and demographic characteristics. Brian Ray and the National Homeschool Education Research Institute found that home-educated students in grades K to 12 were scoring well above public-school students in all subject areasāreading, language, mathematics, social studies, and scienceāon standardized academic achievement tests. Ray, 2010, see above. But schooling, from the time that public schools werefounded until today, has served to cultivate democratic citizenship. Parental rights in education.
Next
Research Revelations about Homeschooling
.jpg)
In 1985, approximately 50,000children were being educated at home. Academic and Policymaker Angst Over Home-Based Education Despite consistent and broad research evidence that homeschooling is associated with positive outcomes, behaviors, and traits, it appears an increasing number of academics and policymakers are expressing concerns about parent-led education. And this lack of definition leads to the more philosophical issues that will be addressed later in this article. More children arehomeschooled than attend conservative Christian academies. If the student lives a great distance away also, the journey may well take too long or prove inconvenient.
Next
Home Schooling: The Pros and Cons
Brian Ray and Dr. This includes topics related to formal institutions catering to students in early childhood, pre-school, primary, elementary, intermediate, secondary, post-secondary, and tertiary education. Homeschooling is the apogee ofparental control over a child's education, where no other institutionhas a claim to influence the schooling of the child. . It is possible, but it is a simple claim and she expects the reader to fill in the missing pieces of how she arrived at her conclusion.
Next
Home Schooling
Just 10 years ago, educating a child at home was illegal in severalstates. Email the Publisher at Publisher TheHomeschoolMagazine. Taking advantage ofthe Internet and other new technologies, more middle-of-the- roadsuburbanites are homeschooling, too. The second part of the political tolerance scale measures the respondent's willingness to extend basic civil liberties to members of his least-liked group" p. Why Are the Home-Educated Doing So Well? For the first,parents can tailor the education environment to their own convictions and totheir beliefs about what their child's needs and interests are. Those reading articles or theses by advocates of the State Authority position should realize that these advocates think the Parental Authority position is wrong and theirs, the State Authority position, is morally or philosophically superior. Their moral reasoning is at least as advanced as that of other children, and they may be more likely to act unselfishly.
Next
The Civic Perils of Homeschooling
. Yet from thestandpoint of citizenship, these other people are equals. However, the fact remains that certain students achieve better in certain environments at all levels of education, and the wellbeing and happiness of the individual must be of the utmost importance. Furthermore, research by Dr. Retrieved March 16, 2011, from 20. The ability to custom-tailor an education for their children is often themotivation for parents to homeschool.
Next
Homeschooling and Tolerance
That is, they generally believe that the state should use its power to exercise final authority over the teaching, training, and indoctrination of children and youth. In order to provide this website free of charge to our readers, Aquila Report uses a combination of donations, advertisements and affiliate marketing links to pay its operating costs. These families are not living in romantic, rural, self-sufficient farmhouses; they are in trailer parks, 1,000-square-foot homes, houses owned by relatives, and some, on tarps in fields or parking lots. It's symptomatic of the unregulatedenvironment of homeschooling that precise figures on the number ofhomeschoolers are impossible to establish. The child is regarded with respect equally to all the children in the class. Who will decide the correct way to measure whether the home-educated student is learning what he or she should learn? Second, their concerns about parent-led home-based education and solutions to alleged problems are driven by something like the State Authority perspective described above.
Next
Critique
Salem, OR: National Home Education Research Institute; Van Pelt, Deani A. Neven, Allison, Patricia A. Home educated and now adults: Their community and civic involvement, views about homeschooling, and other traits. Ray does research and speaking internationally and provides expert testimony to legislators and in courts that focus on homeschooling home-based education, home education, home schooling research and pedagogy. . No doubt this is true.
Next
The Harms of Homeschooling? Where Are the Premises?
. Retrieved February 10, 2010 from www. Education, in my view, isnot a consumption item in the same sense as the food we select from thegrocery store. Although highlycustomized education for students may produce satisfied parents as consumers,and even offer excellent academic training to the student, it is a loss froma civic perspective. Homeschooling Today Homeschooling is more than an education alternative.
Next
How would you like it if you could essentially tutor each one of your students? The importance of the family to the protection of the child. What homeschooled children think about their own social skills is less clear. She offers no research, and no statistics to directly support this claim. Journal of Research on Christian Education, 4 1 , 35-56; Ray, Brian D. The respondent is asked to select the group with beliefs that he opposes the most. Let me put thematter quite simply. However, home schooling is not without its controversies as many non-state school systems arguably are.
Next